Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace Cost Calculator: Ontario 2026 Rates

Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace Cost Calculator (Ontario)

From your Enbridge bills. 2,400 m³ is Enbridge’s “typical residential” figure (includes water heating) – use your own.
Enbridge Rate 1 (Toronto/Ottawa/Niagara), Oct 1 2026: supply 9.4741 + cost adj. 0.5322 + transportation 5.4818 + delivery over 170 m³ 12.2850 = 27.77¢/m³. Other zones differ.
OEB RPP Tier 2 price from Nov 1 2026 = 13.2¢/kWh (commodity only). Add your utility’s per-kWh delivery & regulatory charges from your bill.
95% = Canada’s minimum for new gas furnaces (NRCan). Older furnaces: 60–80%.
2.93 = HSPF 10 (Region V) ÷ 3.412. Use your model’s HSPF ÷ 3.412.
37.5 MJ/m³ (Statistics Canada / NRCan OEE).
Share of heat supplied by backup on the coldest days. 0 = heat pump does it all.

Our heat pump vs gas furnace cost calculator for Ontario compares what you would pay each year to heat your home with natural gas versus a cold-climate heat pump. It uses the Enbridge Gas rates in effect October 1, 2026 and the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) electricity prices that take effect November 1, 2026. Type in the gas you actually burn and the calculator tells you which system costs less to run, and by how much.

How the heat pump vs gas furnace cost calculator works

The calculator does not guess how much heat your home needs. It starts from your own gas use and works out how much heat that gas delivered. Then it asks how much electricity a heat pump would need to deliver the same heat.

  1. Heat delivered: m³ of gas × 37.5 MJ/m³ × furnace AFUE. Divide by 3.6 to get kWh.
  2. Gas cost: m³ × your variable gas price per m³.
  3. Heat pump electricity: heat delivered (kWh) × (1 − backup share) ÷ seasonal COP.
  4. Backup heat: if you keep the furnace as backup (dual fuel), that share is priced as gas. If you use electric strips, it is priced at a COP of 1.
  5. Break-even COP: electricity price × (37.5 ÷ 3.6) × AFUE ÷ gas price. Any heat pump whose seasonal COP beats this number is cheaper to run than your furnace.

Where the default numbers come from

  • Gas price, $0.2777/m³: the sum of the per-m³ charges on Enbridge Gas Rate 1 (EGD rate zone) from October 1, 2026: gas supply 9.4741¢, cost adjustment 0.5322¢, transportation 5.4818¢ and the over-170 m³ delivery block of 12.2850¢. That totals 27.7731¢. The federal carbon charge is $0. Source: the OEB’s October 2026 Enbridge QRAM decision. The fixed $27.69 monthly customer charge is left out because you pay it whatever system you have, unless you disconnect gas entirely.
  • Electricity, $0.132/kWh: the OEB tiered price above the winter threshold from November 1, 2026 (OEB electricity rates). Time-of-use prices are 9.1¢, 14.6¢ and 18.9¢, and ultra-low overnight is 3.7¢. This is the commodity price only. Add your local utility’s delivery and regulatory charges per kWh to get a true comparison.
  • COP 2.93: HSPF 10 (Region V) ÷ 3.412. NRCan reports market heat pumps range from HSPF 7.1 to 13.2 (Region V). Natural Resources Canada explains HSPF and COP on its heat pump guide.
  • AFUE 95%: the federal minimum for most new gas furnaces made since July 3, 2019 (NRCan gas furnace regulations).
  • 37.5 MJ/m³: the energy content of natural gas used by Statistics Canada and NRCan’s Office of Energy Efficiency.

Worked example: heat pump vs gas furnace cost in Toronto

Take a home that burns 2,400 m³ a year with a 95% furnace. A heat pump rated at COP 2.93 is priced at 13.2¢/kWh.

  • Heat delivered: 2,400 × 37.5 × 0.95 = 85,500 MJ ÷ 3.6 = 23,750 kWh
  • Gas cost: 2,400 × $0.2777 = $666.48
  • Heat pump electricity: 23,750 ÷ 2.93 = 8,105.8 kWh × $0.132 = $1,069.97
  • Result: the heat pump costs about $403.49 more per year.
  • Break-even COP: 0.132 × 10.4167 × 0.95 ÷ 0.2777 = 4.70

Now change two inputs. If you heat mostly on the 9.1¢ off-peak price and disconnect gas completely, you save the $332.28 a year customer charge. In that case the heat pump costs $737.63 for energy and you come out $261.13 ahead, with a break-even COP of 3.24. Your electricity price and whether you keep the gas line matter more than almost anything else.

Not sure your current gas use is normal? Read our guide to a high gas bill in winter, or see what changed on Enbridge bills in October 2026.

Assumptions and limits

  • The 2,400 m³ default is Enbridge’s typical residential figure, and it includes water heating. Use only your space-heating gas if you can separate it.
  • One seasonal COP is applied to the whole winter. Real COP falls as it gets colder.
  • Prices exclude HST and the 15.7% Ontario Electricity Rebate on electricity bills.
  • Equipment, installation, maintenance and rebates are not included. See our Ontario heat pump rebate guide.
  • Gas prices are reset every quarter by the OEB, so check the current rate before you decide.

Disclaimer: this calculator gives an energy-cost estimate for education only. It is not a quote or professional advice. Have a licensed HVAC contractor assess your home.

Heat pump vs gas furnace cost: FAQ

Is a heat pump cheaper than gas in Ontario?

Often not on energy alone at November 2026 prices. Gas at about 27.8¢/m³ makes a 95% furnace cheaper unless your heat pump’s seasonal COP is above about 4.7 at 13.2¢/kWh. Cheaper off-peak power, removing the gas connection, or replacing an old 60–80% furnace can flip the result.

What COP should I enter?

Divide your heat pump’s HSPF (Region V if listed) by 3.412. Cold-climate models usually land between 2.5 and 3.5 over a southern Ontario heating season.

Why doesn’t the electricity price include delivery?

Delivery charges differ by local utility. Find the per-kWh delivery and regulatory charges on your bill and add them to the 13.2¢ default.

Should I keep my gas furnace as a backup?

A dual-fuel setup lets the furnace run on the coldest days, when heat pump COP drops. Enter that share as backup heat to see the effect. Keep in mind that keeping gas means you still pay the $27.69 monthly customer charge.

Explore more HVAC tools and calculators.