Could More Heat Pumps Lower Electricity Rates? What RMI’s 2026 Study Found
A new study of heat pump electricity rates asks an unusual question: could adding millions of heat pumps make electricity cheaper for everyone, not just for the homes that install them? The answer from RMI, a clean energy research organization, is a cautious yes, at least in parts of the United States where the power grid has spare capacity in winter. The report, covered by Contracting Business on October 30, 2026, is worth reading in Toronto too, because it explains a grid argument often missing from the debate about heat pump running costs.
Table of Contents
What RMI actually studied
RMI looked at how residential heat pumps could use generation capacity that already exists but sits idle in winter. In many American states, electricity demand peaks in summer, when air conditioning runs hard. That leaves what the report calls winter headroom: capacity available in the colder months.
Its headline estimate is that about 109 million American homes could heat and cool with heat pumps within existing winter grid capacity, about 86 million more than the roughly 23 million that already have heat pumps today. The strategy mixes two kinds of systems, matched to local grid conditions, rather than pushing one setup everywhere.
How heat pump electricity rates could fall
Much of the cost of running a power grid is fixed: poles, wires and power plants must be paid for whether they are used a little or a lot. If heat pumps add electricity sales in winter without forcing a large grid expansion, those fixed costs spread over more kilowatt-hours, putting downward pressure on rates.
That is why the mix matters. RMI estimates that a combined all-electric and hybrid strategy could reduce residential electricity rates by an average of 13 percent in states with available winter capacity, saving about 15.6 billion dollars a year, or roughly 200 dollars per customer. An all-electric-only strategy would cut rates by an average of 6 percent in those states, saving about 6.7 billion dollars a year, or roughly 86 dollars per customer.
Hybrid systems explain the gap. A hybrid pairs an electric heat pump with an existing gas furnace or boiler: the heat pump does most of the annual heating, while the furnace steps in during the coldest hours, when the grid is most stressed. Because a hybrid adds winter use without adding much to the winter peak, it fits about 65 percent more heat pumps into today’s spare winter capacity than all-electric systems alone, according to ACHR News coverage of the same report. Michigan is the strongest example, with about 7.6 gigawatts of winter headroom, enough for heat pumps in 3.6 million additional homes and a possible rate reduction of roughly 27 percent.
What heat pump electricity rates mean for Toronto homes
Read this as a United States finding, not an Ontario promise. Its percentages describe American states with spare winter capacity and cannot be copied onto a Toronto hydro bill; Ontario’s grid, rates and rebates do not appear in RMI’s numbers.
Still, two ideas travel well. First, a hybrid setup suits a Toronto home with a working gas furnace: the furnace covers the coldest hours while the heat pump handles most of the season. Any gas or electrical work involved must be done by a licensed professional. Second, timing matters: RMI recommends installing a heat pump when an existing air conditioner reaches replacement age, rather than replacing a working cooling system early to chase a rate argument. For Ontario money, see our earlier posts on the National Heat Pump Rebate and cold climate heat pumps, and confirm current rules on the official pages first.
What to do about it
- If your air conditioner is near the end of its life, ask a licensed HVAC professional to price both an all-electric and a hybrid heat pump option for your home, so you compare them on your own heating load.
- Ask how each option runs on the coldest nights, and at what outdoor temperature it switches to backup heat.
- Check whether your panel and local distribution can support the new load; RMI notes local systems may need upgrades even where the wider grid has room.
- Do not expect a rate cut on your own bill from this study alone. Its savings are system-wide estimates for heat pump electricity rates, spread across all customers, not a discount promised to any one household.
What the study does not prove
RMI is clear that its findings are directional estimates based on today’s grid conditions, and that results will vary by state and utility. Future demand from data centres, electric vehicles and commercial electrification could also eat into the spare winter capacity the study counts on. Treat the 13 percent figure as a reason to take heat pumps seriously in grid planning, not as a forecast for what any Toronto homeowner will pay next winter.
The useful takeaway is not a number but a shift in thinking: heat pumps are not only a way for one household to heat and cool a home. Deployed in the right mix, at the right time, they can also help use a grid we have already paid for, which is the heart of the heat pump electricity rates argument. Understand that case before your next replacement decision, and check it against Ontario’s own programs and rules rather than importing American percentages.
Browse the residential and commercial guides on this site, read our earlier posts on the National Heat Pump Rebate and cold climate heat pumps, or use the contact page to send a question about a topic you would like covered next.
Sources: RMI report via Contracting Business (October 30, 2026); ACHR News coverage of the RMI report.
